Aquarium Forum banner

Sand vs. Gravel for Cichlids

13K views 16 replies 4 participants last post by  LTruex  
#1 ·
Im hoping I can get some opinions here. I currently have a 55 gallon assorted african cichlid tank and I am always looking for new things to do with this tank or for future tanks I might aquire. What are the benefits/disadvantages to having sand as opposed to gravel at the bottom of an african cichlid tank? I look forward to some feedback!
 
Discussion starter · #5 ·
a rock eater? and these are africans...and they still rearrange the tank around with the gravel lol so it really dont make a difference with that. There arent any fresh water sifter fish are there?
 
Discussion starter · #7 ·
They sold him as Geophagus, but I'm pretty sure it was a species of Satanoperca.

They like to scoop up a mouthful and blow it out their opercula. If he started to run out of sand, he'd get a little neurotic.

Unfortunately, they are very sensitive to nitrogen levels, and he got sick during a brief period of tank neglect, and never did recover. I went a little overboard on the filtration after that...
Would the cichlids pick on it? Or would the fish just be kind of out of the way?
 
Discussion starter · #11 ·
The rockeater was about 7-8 inches when I got him. The firemouth is about 6", and the Dempsey is now getting close to 10.

The rockeaters are supposed to be a good community fish. The guy I bought him from said that they do well in an aggressive tank because the others will leave him alone. Apart from the firemouth being a jerk, that seemed to be the case.
What kind of sand do you use for your tank? would it be good for the africans?
 
Discussion starter · #13 ·
I just used play sand, and spent a lot of time washing it. It's pretty much inert, so I can't see how it would be harmful, but I've never had African cichlids, so I don't know a thing about keeping them.

I will say that I have read that the fish will be more shy if you have a light substrate, and my fish do seem more reclusive with the light substrate I have (it is light gravel) than in other tanks I have had with darker substrate,
oh ok. this has all helped!! thank you