Well, I've never owned a goldfish and I'm thinking of getting one. I'm very low on space and I was just wondering what the minimum tank size for a small healthy goldfish is? As much as i'd love to have something close to a 50g, I think I need to stick to something under 10...and if thats to small I just won't get one at all. Let me know what you think

__________________
Fish are living creatures...treat them that way

2g with 1 female betta

8 gallon with 3 young, adorable bettas and a bumblebee platy or 2 soon to come!

check out my new blog! http://epicaquariumphotography.blogspot.com/

You could actually put a 20 gal in about the same area as a 10. A goldfish would be much happier with more swimming room.

__________________
SUCCESS IS MEASURED BY YEARS, NOT MONTHS!!!
220 Tank build
http://www.aquariumforum.com/f15/sta...late-3253.html

Yea, thats what I want, but my mom is super fidgety about tank size, I'm lucky she's even letting me get a 10g xD

__________________
Fish are living creatures...treat them that way

2g with 1 female betta

8 gallon with 3 young, adorable bettas and a bumblebee platy or 2 soon to come!

check out my new blog! http://epicaquariumphotography.blogspot.com/

I've kept a few goldfish varieties in 10 gallon tanks. 1 at a time mind you. IMO since the smaller the tank, the more trouble to keep healthy, I personally wouldn't do it again. Goldfish are very dirty, & my moor quickly outgrew the tank, constant issues with ammonia despite it having been fully cycled & constant water changes.

I've heard it said that you should give a goldfish (dirty fish) 3 gallons of water per inch of adult fish... So keep in mind the adult size of the fish if you decide to go ahead with it. A 3" sarasa comet for example looks like he's done growing, but the reality is he can grow to 14" give or take. (I have 1 in a 55 gallon though he does have some company, mind you.)

My sister recently set up her first 10 gallon & put a common pleco (also a dirty fish) in it along with a blue gourami. Personally, I feel bad for that pleco since he's gonna get big, far too big for that tank. (I think they grow to 12"-18".)

My current 10 gallon tank houses 1 male betta & 2 female dwarf gourami. They get along beautifully, swim together, etc. Water quality hasn't been an issue either.

__________________
-Never put a Chinese Algae Eater in a Guppy tank unless you enjoy vacuuming little corpses out of the substrate.-

55 Gallon/brackish (1.009)-
1 dragon goby
5 black mollies
4 bumblebee gobies
14 ghost shrimp
2 snails of unknown species

20 Gallon/freshwater/planted-
3 zebra danios
2 snail of unknown species

10 Gallon/freshwater-
currently fishless

Yea, I think i'm gonna steer clear of a goldie for now ;)

__________________
Fish are living creatures...treat them that way

2g with 1 female betta

8 gallon with 3 young, adorable bettas and a bumblebee platy or 2 soon to come!

check out my new blog! http://epicaquariumphotography.blogspot.com/

BlueSaphire:

You are wise to avoid a godlfish. They get huge and need 20-30 gallons each, besides being messy. I think one betta OR a few guppies (don't do both) might be a good choice. Either are really colorful and fun!

If you go with guppies, either get males or females but not both -- or they'll breed and you'll soon have dozens, and no space to put them!

Good luck

Gautam

Goldfish are very messy fish and theylive in at least a 10 gal (20 gal would be better) and at least weekly water changes. The bigger the tank, the easier it is to maintain.

Yea, I've decided not to get one :P

__________________
Fish are living creatures...treat them that way

2g with 1 female betta

8 gallon with 3 young, adorable bettas and a bumblebee platy or 2 soon to come!

check out my new blog! http://epicaquariumphotography.blogspot.com/

A bowl is all you need what the ****.

ChopperBlue,

I used to think that a bowl was all that was needed -- and lost quite a few fish that way. I researched it on the net, and realized the goldfish -- if allowed to live their full lifespan of 20-30 years-- grow to 12-18 inches long!! You can validate this -- just check out the nearest goldfish pond (not aquarium tank) and you'll see these huge fish...

Many people 'succeed' in keeping goldfish in bowls for a couple of years or three. But they become stunted and die and it's a bad death. Apparently, the fish's body stop growing, but it's internal organs keep growing... and become compressed and deformed until it can;t live any more. Sounds ugly, no?

GB

o_O Yea, actually it's 10-20 gallon minimum per fish with filtration.

__________________
Fish are living creatures...treat them that way

2g with 1 female betta

8 gallon with 3 young, adorable bettas and a bumblebee platy or 2 soon to come!

check out my new blog! http://epicaquariumphotography.blogspot.com/

It all depends what type of gold fish you get, and how small you get to start with, as in, you could keep one in a 20gl tank for years before it needs a bigger tank.

Im not sure what people are going on about that they take a lot of work, are hard to keep. I've had mine for a few years and I'll tell you what, its been alot easier than tropical fish.
I have not worried about the water at all apart from Aquasafe and I assure you my fish have not suffered at all, in fact quite the opposite as you can see in the photos, the first being one from a few months after I got them, the other two taken a few weeks ago. I am in the process of getting a bigger tank for them now, but they have been happy & healthy enough in my 20lt tank.

Photo 1 Photo 2 Photo 3

The more water the better. Personally my thoughts are anything over 3 inches should be in at least a 20 gallon. Im in the process of planting a 20 gallon now for my 2 inch fantail. He is in a 10 gallon now and while he is doing fine I want to get him into the 20 where he will remain unless he grows bigger than the 6 inch average. Stunting and quality of life should be the concern when keeping fish and goldfish can live to be old but not in cramped quarters where poor water quality is an issue. 3 gallons per inch of fish is the calculation I use for goldfish.

Well, im considering getting a goldfish or two, for one i think a 20 G would do fine, but i would always try to aim as alrge as you can! =-)

__________________
Who Says a Decent Fish-Keeper cant be A 12 Year old?
BAN THE BOWL!!

Ok so lets put goldfish in a bowl! Hummmm I wonder if either one of these would fit.

__________________
SUCCESS IS MEASURED BY YEARS, NOT MONTHS!!!
220 Tank build
http://www.aquariumforum.com/f15/sta...late-3253.html

That sounds awful.

I got a comet goldfish about 2 years ago when it was approx 3.5 inches long, now it has almost doubled in size. In the past few months it has become very apparent that the 60 litres tank was getting too small for the comet goldfish (and Chinese algae eater as well) so I've just bought a new 160 litres tank and once it's ready the two fish will be moved to the new tank.

__________________
.
.
TANK - Marina Style 160, Eheim 2213 and a 150w heater.
FISH COMMUNITY - 2 Pearl Gourami, 4 Scissortail Rasbora, 2 Guppies and 7 Neon Tetras.