living in a pickle jar - Aquarium Forum
Freshwater Tank Builds This forum is where you may post pictures and descriptions, as well as progress reports of setting up your new freshwater tank. This includes any type of freshwater system, such as fish only, live plants, freshwater invert tanks, etc.

  Members currently in the chatroom: 0
Who's Online
The most chatters online in one day was 17, 09-12-2012.
No one is currently using the chat.

LinkBack Thread Tools
post #1 of 7 (permalink) Old 04-14-2012, 11:00 PM Thread Starter
Master of Algae (THE MOA)
Join Date: Aug 2010
Posts: 545
Thanks: 6
Thanked 317 Times in 212 Posts
Welcomes: 51
Welcomed 9 Times in 1 Post
living in a pickle jar

at some point, nearly every aquarist dreams about a tiny representation of a piece of the earth that is completely closed off from all environmental input. you know what i mean, the ecosphere type setups that are completely sealed, only letting light in and very rarely, if ever, air. it is a beautiful idea, it is essentially creating a microcosm, a single window into the entire process that take place on earth. you know, the process we passingly refer to as ecology. it is a dream that has been with aquarists and naturalists for years. some say it has never been done, many say it cannot be done.

that last assumption is complete BS. the one prior only partially so.

before i explain that it is not only possible, but indeed very simple, to create a self sustaining closed system, let me dispell any delusions of grandure that may be building up in anyones head...

you will never be able to keep a healthy autolinking image in a closed ten gallon aquarium.


i have spent the last fifteen years or so getting closer and closer to that holy grail of aquariums, and i have learned a LOT of lessons along the way. here are a few things i have learned and come to realize that may help someone else who chooses to pursue this "unsolved equation".

first and formost is the size and complexity of the animals and plants that are to be kept in a sealed system. lets say we take a small fish, the dwarf livebearer (heterandria formosa), and a simple plant, java moss, and put them together in ten gallon and seal the lid. we will add light and keep the temperature stable, but that is about it. the rest is up to the fish and the plant.
ok, so we have a fish that will live a lonely life in ten gallon tank. that would be kind of like giving you about half an acre of living space. in fact, you would have about half an acre of lawn, about 60 feet of space above your head, and lightly filtered sunlight. now, lets place ourselves into the fins of our new sealed systems inhabitant. for a little while, things are ok, kinda lonely, but hey, at least you have some room to move around. after a little while, you start to get hungry. this is a problem... there really isnt much to eat, but if you look really hard, you can usually find some tiny bits of dying plant matter to eat, as well as the ocasional tiny copepod here and there. its a good thing you have a tough stomache, otherwise you might be in trouble. so food is taken care of, for now. as the first day drags on, things seem not so bad, the light is hitting the plants and the plants are quickly using up all that annoying CO2 in the water with you, giving you plenty of nice fresh oxygen to breath. along with the CO2, the plants are also soaking up all the nasty stuff that you release with your number ones and number twos. the food sucks, but hey, you cant really complain too much.

later on in the day, god decides to turn off the lights. you expected this, nothing new. after a little while however, that nice little oxygen bar you had sitting on top of that nasty tasting plant starts to get a little stuffy. you see, plants only exchange oxygen for carbon dioxide while the lights are on. without the photo in photosynthesis, plants have to use oxygen from the water and expell excess CO2, which they can no longer use. as the new king of your own little ecosystem, this translates into a really lousy day. the CO2 levels are rising, the O2 levels are dropping, and that friendly plant which is now using oxygen faster than you are, doesnt seem so friendly anymore. not only that, the water is getting sharp! by the end of the night, there is so much CO2 in the water that the PH has dropped to dangerous levels and you are really starting to feel the heat. the acid water has left your gills inflamed and you are starting to feel like you are literally suffocating. it wont be long before you slip into unconsiousness...

about this time god(the "benevolent" owner of your new little world) decides to be merciful to you again and turns the light on. slowly, you come out of your oxygen deprivation induced stupor and start to look around. it seems your not the only one who suffered last night. that plant you were hanging out at yesterday has several leaves that look soft and pale, with tiny holes in them. it obviously had a lot of trouble last night, as several patches of it have begun to die back. that means more lousy tasting food for you, which is great and all, except that you still feel sick from last night and really have ZERO appetite. after a while though, the parts of the plant that are still alive soak up a lot of the CO2 and things start to get a little more tolerable. the water never quite returns to that freshness that it had on that first day, but eventually you feel good enough to get hungry. this time, there is plenty of dead and half dead plant for you to eat. with nothing else to eat, you gobble it down. by this point you are relatively comfortable again. what is left of the dying plant is starting to rot, so the place is getting a bit stinky, but you arent hungry and at least you dont feel like you are suffocating anymore.

then someone turns off the lights again. you begin to go through the same hell you went through last night, only this time its worse. the plant is sucking up oxygen again, but its not the plant that is bothering you, its the combination of the plant and the bacteria that are eating the dead plant parts that are sending you for a loop this time. if it were just the plant, it wouldnt be so bad. the ph and CO2/O2 swings would be less severe tonight than they were last night, as there is less plant to compete with you now. add that pesky bacteria culture though, and now you have a recipe for disaster. by the time the lights come back on you are barely alive, sitting at the bottom of your tank gasping for air in an oxygen deprived coma.

eventually you wake up feeling absolutely miserable. during the night, your body shut down all non-essential processes. that means you took a nice massive number two while you were out of it. that really sucks, because you werent even done digesting that food. your situation now is looking pretty bleak. the water never really returns to the state it was on that first day as the bacteria are using up any extra oxygen just as fast as the remainder of the plant can produce. on top of that, you are slowly suffocating, you are weak from not really being able to even eat the nasty nutrient deplete food you ate yesterday, and you have have digested strings of plant matter hanging out your back end. you try moving around to several places in the tank, looking for better water. its useless, it all sucks. unfortunately, the god of your world sees you swimming around slowly and thinks that you are doing fine. to him, you must be healthy, so he keeps up what is obviously working.

later, he never fully understands why you were dead the next morning.

so, now everyone should be clear on why you would never be able to simply seal some fish up and have any positive results. now that that is clear, on to the second half of this incredibly long winded post...

Replicating Nature

the first mistake i see in almost every system that i have seen that supposedly recreates mother earth is that the lights go off at night. it is a rediculous notion that because we have a night, no light should reach a closed system for half of every day. let me dispell this myth: a closed system should ALWAYS have a light on it. this may not make sense at first, but think about it, when does the sun not shine on the earth? at night? nope, just shines on the other side. we are still connected to the side the sun shines on by the biosphere. if you were to completely replicate nature, you would need two tanks that can circulate water and maybe air between them and only light one at a time. you would never under any circumstances turn off both lights. well, you certainly could if you wanted too, but it would be nothing like earth, which is always bathed in sunlight.

the second mistake i often see is the assumption that a fish, provided with a plant that it can eat, will be able to live off of that plant. from time to time i still see bettas being sold with a bamboo shoot in its bowl with the idea that the autolinking image will live happily off of the roots of the plant. its the same kind of mistake that uneducated pet owners make when they assume that feeding their turtles and bearded dragons lots and lots of lettuce will keep them healthy. if you were to replicate nature, you would have to create a system that can grow enough food to meet ALL of the nutritional requirements of its highest level organisms as well as maintain good gas and nitrogen levels. you would also have to find a way to safeguard your food populations from extinction. this means that at least some of each species would have to be protected from the animals that eat them so that they can produce a constant supply of food. without this, you will never be able to reach or maintain a balanced ecosystem.

the third mistake i see is the misconceptions about size. im talking about the living-thing-to-environmental-space-ratio(aint that a mouth full). to put the good ol reference(nature) into perspective, think about how big living things get on earth. then imagine the size of earth itself. put the two next to each other and you start to get my point. if you were to put even a tiny dwarf livebearer into a ten gallon tank it would be like expecting a creature half the size of the moon to live on earth. if you have ever tried sealing a container and saw what lived after a year, you would have noticed that the things that remain generaly need a microscope to examin. life does not die out completely as long as energy can go into the system(light), but nothing big lives for long.
this is what i meant by a sealed self sustaining closed system being quite simple to set up. the question is not about whether it is possible or not, but rather about the definition of success. personally, i find microscopic life to be just as fascinating as macroscopic. a closed system can certainly sustain microscopic life for seemingly indefinite periods of time, therefore a balanced closed system can be created, at least by definition. well, sort of... a truely closed system that actually lives would break the third law of thermodynamics... but thats beside the point.

now, after having said all this, i still believe that it is possible to create a sealed system that can support fish. it would just have to be very complex, with ways to circulate resources around it while maintaining a balance of the resources and life within it. i for one am going to continue to find ways of creating this system. my goal is to be able to create a system that can live for 20 or more years without any resource input except for light and heat energy. i believe i am a lot closer than most, and i believe it is possible, even though i am highly skeptical of even myself.

anyway, i hope you all enjoyed the long read and maybe walk away from it either inspired or enlightened. my hope is that someday someone will create what i view as the holy grail of all aquariums.

who knows, maybe it will even be you?

You show me a man who can reliably grow algae and I will show you a man who can reliably grow fish.

Last edited by Auban; 04-14-2012 at 11:07 PM.
Auban is offline  
Said thanks:
Sponsored Links
post #2 of 7 (permalink) Old 04-15-2012, 12:43 AM
Pleco n bn breeder n BOSS
Super Moderator
susankat's Avatar
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Tulsa, Ok
Posts: 7,677
Thanks: 2,662
Thanked 3,518 Times in 2,660 Posts
Welcomes: 6,465
Welcomed 13 Times in 1 Post
Re: living in a pickle jar

Even though its long winded, it is a very interesting read. Thanks for the post.

220 Tank build + 62 other tanks.
susankat is offline  
post #3 of 7 (permalink) Old 04-15-2012, 11:47 AM
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: SAN DIEGO CA
Posts: 10
Thanks: 3
Thanked 2 Times in 2 Posts
Welcomes: 5
Welcomed 19 Times in 1 Post
Re: living in a pickle jar

Interesting thoughts....well written
TIN BENDER is offline  
post #4 of 7 (permalink) Old 04-15-2012, 12:39 PM
Kehy's Avatar
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: Ellensburg, Washington
Posts: 1,694
Thanks: 179
Thanked 556 Times in 509 Posts
Welcomes: 411
Welcomed 19 Times in 1 Post
Re: living in a pickle jar

tell this to all the people wanting to do biospheres.

I have done a non-sealed, solar powered biosphere of sorts sitting in my window with just snails and plants. I add co2 and top off the water sometimes, but no filtration or water changes and no feeding. Some of the plants are doing alright (frequent crypt melt though), but the thing is, some of my oldest snails are in the jar, and and this jar has been set up for nearly 6 months, yet they are half the size of the ones in the larger, filtered tank that are only about 3 months old!

Adopt one today!
Lead me not to temptation...I can find my own way there, thank you
Kehy is offline  
post #5 of 7 (permalink) Old 04-15-2012, 06:59 PM Thread Starter
Master of Algae (THE MOA)
Join Date: Aug 2010
Posts: 545
Thanks: 6
Thanked 317 Times in 212 Posts
Welcomes: 51
Welcomed 9 Times in 1 Post
Re: living in a pickle jar

same thing happens with fish. i had a population of very stunted dwarf livebearers for about five years that i never fed, i just made sure that the food items could not all be eaten at once. that particular reproducing population of fish is the healthiest population of fish i have ever seen in a strictly no-feed tank, even though they were incredibly stunted. at least they were able to reproduce.

im starting to believe that there needs to be a predator of some sort to eat some of the baby fish. this would leave fewer in the population, more food for the individuals left, and hopefully a more healthy population overall. in nature, this happens. finding a species that fits the bill for an aquarium is not going to be easy though. i was thinking of using dragonfly larvae for this, but that would only work for a couple of years, and only if i had a way to make sure they couldnt eat ALL the fry.

then again, maybe i just need to try it... you never know, i may end up inadvertantly creating a strain were the fry school closely with the parents, avoiding the "predators of the deep".

You show me a man who can reliably grow algae and I will show you a man who can reliably grow fish.
Auban is offline  
post #6 of 7 (permalink) Old 04-15-2012, 09:39 PM
Join Date: Jun 2011
Posts: 283
Thanks: 703
Thanked 123 Times in 97 Posts
Welcomes: 29
Welcomed 28 Times in 2 Posts
Re: living in a pickle jar

When I was in college, a biology major, back in '67 I was given a test tube about the size of a man's index finger which contained a male guppy- and a 2" piece of anachris or elodea (I can't remember) creating a closed world. It sat on my dorm window for 2 years until I released "Hector" into my 10 gallon desk aquarium. It took several more months before he ventured below the top half inch of water.
ArtyG is offline  
post #7 of 7 (permalink) Old 04-16-2012, 07:26 AM
The reason Susan is crazy
Crazy's Avatar
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: southwest Louisiana
Posts: 549
Thanks: 3
Thanked 241 Times in 208 Posts
Welcomes: 161
Welcomed 22 Times in 1 Post
Re: living in a pickle jar

One thing I think you should be commended on is that in your system you are very aware of the health of all plants/fish in the tank. This is what I feel sets this method apart from other methods. Instead of just saying see I can do it, you are looking for a way to make all living organisms thrive within the system instead of just surviving. I look forward to seeing your progress as this develops.

Does not play well with stupid.
Crazy is offline  

Quick Reply

Register Now

In order to be able to post messages on the Aquarium Forum forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.

User Name:
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.


Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.

Email Address:


Human Verification

In order to verify that you are a human and not a spam bot, please enter the answer into the following box below based on the instructions contained in the graphic.

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Show Printable Version
Email this Page Email this Page

Posting Rules  
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On

For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome