I think that number 1 has a bit better personality. Number 2 seemed a bit aggressive. Otherwise they are both beautiful. I feel for you have to decide which one to remove. Good luck.

__________________
1 55 gallon tank

1 Oscar
1 Blood Parrot Cichlid
2 Frontosa Cichlids
1 Pleco
1 Tiger Barb

1 10 gallon Tank

1 Betta
10 Neon Tetras
3 Danios
2 Mollys
2 Platys
3 Tiger Barbs