Had a difficult decision as well. i think that both tanks had alot of effort put into them. Im not a big fan of the sunken ship type decor, and well the fine white gravel and the enclosed top makes for difficult (frequent) vaccums. I cast my vote, based on what i didn;t like, instead of what i did like. (which is the apparent health of the fish [not knowing the ages])

gratz, to whom ever is the winner